Does the Reformed Doctrine of Inerrancy Threaten Christian Libertarians?

Culture, Originally Published on The Libertarian Christian Institute, The Parlor, Theology

The Libertarian Christian Institute is an ecumenical Christian organization which brings together Christians from a variety of theological backgrounds. Though our theological differences don’t affect libertarianism, sometimes they intersect it. And when this happens, it’s prudent to share and grapple with our differing perspectives.


Peter Enns is a Westminster trained Biblical scholar, holds a Ph.D from Harvard, and he objects to the inerrancy of scripture.1 He objects because Christians can’t agree on everything the bible affirms and teaches. While Enns questions the historicity of much of Scripture, he says, “portions of Scripture that do rightly affirm/teach include the 10 Commandments, Jesus’s teachings on forgiveness, the Beatitudes, and many other things.” These things are true, Enns argues, because they’re related to faith and salvation. Enns illustrates his point using Romans 13; the thorn in the flesh of Christian libertarians.

Peter Enns and Romans 13

Enns agrees that Paul is teaching/affirming something, but whatever it is, the standard interpretation of Romans 13 runs counter to the founding of America, which is born from an act of violence and treason.2 So what gives? Enns has a valid complaint here. How do we interpret Romans 13?

Enns points out common concerns with the text given we believe it doesn’t apply to certain situations.3 Of course, this nuance isn’t explicit either; we must infer it by considering other passages like Acts 5:29, which incidentally, and perhaps ironically, is in the context of disobeying religious authorities.

So what exactly is Enns’ problem with inerrancy?
To answer that, I need to unravel it from Biblicism.

Enns’ isn’t ignorant of the Chicago Statement of Biblical Inerrancy (CSBI). He’s penned several books, and one of them resulted in his suspension from Westminster Theological Seminary. Despite his Reformed education, I found myself confused by his stance. In fact, upon reading his contribution to the Five Views of Biblical Inerrancy, I realized that he’s conflating Biblicism with inerrancy.4

Why is this a confusion? Krisis and Praxis gives an excellent overview of the varying degrees of inerrancy. At the top, is Biblicism. But Biblicism doesn’t appear to be the position of A.A. Hodge and B.B. Warfield, the writers from Old Princeton who drafted the doctrine of inspiration.

Read More

Join Mere Liberty

My content is free and audience supported. Members enjoy premium access. Click here to learn more.

Become a Member!

Thanks!

Join Mere Liberty

My content is free and audience supported. Members enjoy premium access. Click here to learn more.

Become a Member!

Thanks!

Kerry Baldwin 

Thanks for visiting my website! Add your thoughts and comments by contacting me below, or you can interact with me and my patrons by becoming a premium member at mereliberty.com/membership.

Follow Me

Amazon Goodreads Apple Podcasts Google Podcasts Spotify Feedly YouTube

  Gift Jar

w

In lieu of a comments section

I welcome and encourage your thoughts, comments, and questions through email.


Related Posts

The Virulence of Moral Panic

The Virulence of Moral Panic

The COVID-19 outbreak is front and center in everyone’s mind. Emotions run high as states across the US have ordered people to stop working and stay home. Some people have been able to keep their jobs and work from home, while others have lost their jobs. (As of this...

How do I work from home and homeschool my kids?

How do I work from home and homeschool my kids?

How do I work from home and homeschool my kids? Facebook Livestream How do I work from and homeschool my kids? Working from home is nothing like working in the office. And when you have kids around, requiring your attention, it can become stressful. To cope with this,...

The Great Abortion Debate: A Chat With Kerry Baldwin GodArchy #33

The Great Abortion Debate: A Chat With Kerry Baldwin GodArchy #33

The Great Abortion Debate: A Chat With Kerry Baldwin GodArchy #33 GodArchy Podcast | Show Notes Few issues are as binary and divisive as abortion. But the standard “pro-life” and “pro-choice” positions in American politics have utterly failed to adequately deal with...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This